Sling TV vs YouTube TV: Price, Channels and DVR

Sling TV costs $13 to $22 a month less than YouTube TV for its fullest plan. What you give up for that: CBS, most local channels and an unlimited DVR.

Prices and lineups last checked .

Key points

  • Sling Orange & Blue is $60.99 to $69.99 a month against $82.99 for YouTube TV, so the saving is $13 to $22.
  • YouTube TV includes ABC, CBS, NBC and Fox in most areas. Sling has Fox, ABC and NBC in select markets; CBS is not listed.
  • YouTube TV's DVR is unlimited. Sling includes 50 hours and charges $5 a month for unlimited.
  • Sling wins on price only if you choose one of its smaller plans or use an antenna for local stations.

Sling TV is cheaper than YouTube TV, and YouTube TV is more complete. Sling’s fullest plan, Orange & Blue, costs $60.99 to $69.99 a month depending on where you live, against $82.99 for YouTube TV. For the difference you give up CBS, dependable local channels, an unlimited DVR and about half the channels. Whether that is a good trade depends on how you get your local stations.

This comparison uses each service’s published plans and prices. We have not run hands-on tests of either.

Side by side

Sling Orange & Blue YouTube TV
Regular price $60.99 to $69.99 a month $82.99 a month
Channels 50+ 100+
Local stations Fox, ABC and NBC in select markets; CBS not listed ABC, CBS, NBC and Fox, by ZIP code
ESPN Yes Yes
FS1 and NFL Network Yes Yes
Cloud DVR 50 hours; unlimited for $5 a month Unlimited, included
Recordings kept 9 months 9 months
Streams at once Up to 4, with limits 3
Free trial None 10 days on most plans
Contract None None

Price: closer than it looks

Sling advertises “from” prices, and they rise where a plan includes local stations. At the Chicago ZIP code Sling’s site showed us, with Fox, NBC and ABC included, Orange & Blue was $69.99. Add unlimited DVR to match YouTube TV and it is $74.99.

At that point the gap is $8 a month, and YouTube TV still has CBS and roughly twice the channels. Sling’s advertised starting price for Orange & Blue is $60.99, a $22 gap, but we could not confirm which markets pay it, and without local stations you need another way to get every local network.

Sling is clearly cheaper only when you do not buy the combined plan:

Sling plan Price What you get
Essentials $19.99 10+ channels including ESPN and ESPN2
Orange $45.99 30+ channels including ESPN, Disney Channel, CNN, TNT and TBS
Blue $45.99 to $54.99 40+ channels including FS1, NFL Network, Fox News, USA, CNN, TNT and TBS

YouTube TV has smaller plans too. Its Sports plan is $64.99 and its Entertainment plan $54.99, and both include the local networks. The Sports plan costs less than Sling Orange & Blue in a market like Chicago.

Local channels: the deciding factor

YouTube TV shows ABC, CBS, NBC and Fox on every plan, with the actual stations set by your home ZIP code.

Sling’s coverage is partial in three ways. It offers Fox, ABC and NBC only in select markets. Its Orange plan has no local stations at all. And CBS does not appear on any Sling page we read. For the NFL alone that matters, since CBS carries a large share of Sunday afternoon games; see how to watch the NFL without cable.

Sling’s own answer is an antenna, and it is a reasonable one. If an antenna picks up your local stations, Sling’s weakness mostly disappears, and you can buy Orange alone at $45.99 instead of the combined plan. Two cautions: Sling says channels from an antenna cannot be recorded on its DVR, and you should confirm reception first with the TV antenna guide.

Sports channels

Both carry ESPN, FS1, NFL Network, TNT and TBS, provided you take Orange & Blue on the Sling side. Orange alone has no FS1 or NFL Network, and Blue alone has no ESPN.

YouTube TV’s main plan goes further, with ESPNU, SEC Network, Big Ten Network, NBA TV and CBS Sports Network in its lineup. On Sling several of those need Sports Extra, which is $15 a month on Orange & Blue.

NFL RedZone is an add-on with both: Sports Plus at $10.99 on YouTube TV, and Sports Extra on Sling.

DVR and streams

YouTube TV’s DVR is unlimited and included. Sling includes 50 hours, which a household that records sport or several series will fill quickly, and sells unlimited recording for $5 a month. Both keep recordings for nine months.

Streams are less simple than the numbers suggest. YouTube TV allows three at once on any channel. Sling Orange & Blue allows up to four, but only one of them can be on ESPN or a Disney channel at a time, and Orange alone allows a single stream.

Devices

Both run on Roku, Fire TV, Apple TV, Google TV and recent Samsung, LG and Vizio televisions. YouTube TV lists PlayStation and Xbox consoles; Sling lists Xbox but not PlayStation.

Which to choose

Your situation Choose
You want one app with all your local networks and no decisions YouTube TV
You have an antenna and want ESPN and a few cable channels Sling Orange
You want cable news and entertainment channels more than sport Sling Blue
You record a lot YouTube TV, or Sling with unlimited DVR added to the price
You want to try before paying YouTube TV; Sling has no free trial
You would buy Sling Orange & Blue with locals and unlimited DVR Compare carefully; YouTube TV costs about $8 more and includes more

Each service has a longer write-up: the Sling TV review and the YouTube TV review. If neither fits, best live TV streaming services covers the rest, and cheapest live TV streaming services covers the plans below Sling’s price.

Sources